The Greatest Collection of Costa Rican Coins Ever Auctioned (Part 1): The Event
Filed Under: Spinks, Auction News, Featured, General Collecting, World Coins
by Greg Reynolds for Coinlink
On Oct. 23, the late Frederick Mayer’s collection of Costa Rican coins, tokens and paper money was auctioned by the firm of Spink-Smythe in New York City. The day before, Oct. 22, Spink-Shreves sold Mayer’s collection of Costa Rican stamps at the same location. The Shreves stamp auction firm and Smythe are now integrated and owned by Spink. This first part of my review concerns the setting and atmosphere of the auction, the general importance of the material that was sold, the consignor, and the participants. In part 2, I will discuss Costa Rican silver coins.
The highest priced coin in the auction was Mayer’s Costa Rican 1873 Twenty Pesos gold coin. The issue is a Great Rarity. The Mayer 1873 realized $43,225. Curiously, it weighs substantially more than two Costa Rican Ten Pesos coins, and almost as much as a U.S. Double Eagle ($20 gold coin). It will be discussed in Part 3, along with other gold coins from the collection, a few of which are incredible.
Some of the rarer, most famous, and more interesting of Mayer’s coins were minted when Costa Rica was part of the Central American Republic, which was really a loose federation that was founded in 1823 and began to fall apart in 1838. These coins will be discussed in Part 4.
Costa Rica is a stable democracy in Central America. It borders Panama and Nicaragua. El Salvador, the Honduras and Guatemala are also in Central America, which is a landmass that is connected to both North America and South America. World coin collectors in the U.S. and Europe often aim to build type sets of all Central American or of all Latin American societies.
An excellent assortment of other Latin American coins, from a few different consignors, was auctioned the following day, Oct. 24. Matt Orsini, the primary cataloguer, reveals that “all” of the coins of Argentina “came from one consignor.” It was thus an extraordinary collection of coins from this nation. An 1845 Eight Escudos (large gold coin) is an important rarity. This PCGS graded AU-58 Eight Escudos was minted in La Rioja in 1845 and was the last gold coin of the era of General Rosas. It sold for $8625. (more…)

Spink
A unique discovery note will be auctioned by
London, England - Spink, the world’s leading auctioneers of Coins, Stamps, Medals and Banknotes, Bonds and Share Certificates, based in London and established 1666, has acquired R.M. Smythe & Company, specialists in Antique Stocks and Bonds, Banknotes, Coins, and Autographs, based in New York City and established in 1880. Both Spink and Smythe are known around the globe for their illustrious histories, impeccable reputations and unparalleled expertise. The merging of these two companies is the next logical step in line with Spink’s strategy for the future and will create the first truly global, fully integrated, collectables house.















