Over 100 Overton Varieties in the Bayside New York Collection
The Bayside New York Collection contains an incredible 100-plus half dollars minted between 1794 and 1807. Heritage will offer this wonderful assemblage as a Featured Collection in the upcoming 2008 July-August Baltimore, MD (ANA) US Coin Signature Auction.
Early half dollars are a favorite - albeit challenging - series among advanced collectors. Their fascination with die varieties is one of the very oldest traditions in American numismatics. Using his keen eye, the consignor assembled a collection featuring an abundance of beautiful variety examples over many years. The collection is sure to attract early half specialists, as well as type collectors seeking beauty and rarity.
Without any question, the cream of the Bayside New York Collection is the complete selection of 1796-1797 varieties. This is the second time that all four varieties of the Draped Bust, Small Eagle type consigned from one collection has crossed the Heritage auction block; the first time was the Reiver collection in January 2006. To put this achievement in its proper context, we are aware of only three other times ever that an auction has contained all four varieties from a single consignor.
The Bayside name came from the area where the consignor grew up and discovered coin collecting. He bought his first group of bust halves (about 20 of them, at 55-cents each!) late in WWII, when a neighborhood friend needed to raise cash. With a library copy of Beistle as his guide, he started down the path to becoming an expert in the series. Over the decades, while he collected many different series, he always pursued the early halves first. Even while stationed in the Pacific, this career Navy officer was able to continue collecting, thanks to the excellent FPO mail system. When stateside, he entertained Al Overton in his home. After his retirement, he took tables at dozens of coin shows to get first crack at the early halves on the market.
Highlights, many of which have video descriptions, of the Bayside New York Collection include:
- 1794 50C, O-101 VF30 NGC.
- 1794 50C, O-106, R.6 VF35 NGC.
- 1795 50C Two Leaves, O-101, R.7 VF20 NGC.
- 1795 50C 2 Leaves, O-105 XF40 NGC.
- 1795 50C 2 Leaves, O-106, R.6 VF20 NGC.
- 1795 50C Two Leaves, O-120, Low R.7 XF Details NCS.
- 1796 50C 15 Stars, O-101, R.5 AU58 PCGS.
- 1796 50C 16 Stars, O-102, High R.5 VF30 PCGS.
- 1797 50C O-101a, High R.4 VF30 NGC.
- 1797 50C O-102, Low R.6 VF35 PCGS.
- 1805/4 50C O-103, R.5 XF40 NGC.
Related Articles
- Pre-ANA Auctions Preview, Part II of III: Half Dollars
- Historic Ed Price Collection of Early Dimes & Quarter Eagles to be offered by Heritage
- The Super-Rare 1825 O-118 Bust Half to be offered by Heritage
- Four Great Heritage Auctions in Long Beach
- The most interesting collection to be auctioned at the 2008 ANA Convention: The Dimes & $2½ gold coins of Ed Price
- Extensive collection of U.S. Copper, Nickel & Silver to be auctioned on Feb. 26 & 27: Rich Uhrich’s coins
- The Walter J. Husak Collection of Large Cents
- Bowers and Merena to Auction Leading PCGS Registry Set of Lincoln Cents in August
- Proof 1838-O Half and Husak Large Cents Lead Heritage Long Beach Sale
- Stack’s Baltimore Auction - A Memorable 1796 No-Stars Quarter Eagle
- Gold Tops Bowers and Merena Lots
- Stack’s Discovers New Wood’s Hibernia Obverse
- The Ted Naftzger Collection of United States Large Cents to be Sold
- Virtually Complete Early Large Cent Collection of Walter Husak to be Auctioned
- The Glenn E. Bergstrom Collection to be offered by Stacks
- Kiawah Collection of Gold Coins Highlights Summer FUN Offerings
- Some Thoughts on Proof Bust Silver Coinage: Part One - Half Dimes and Dimes
- Gold Hot in Heritage’s May 2008 Long Beach $26.5 Million Auction
- 1846 Shipwreck Yields Southern Gold and Capped Bust Halves
- Rarest Half Cent Brings $345,000: The Rouse 1796 ‘No Pole’!
About the Author
Heritage Auction Galleries is the world's largest collectibles auctioneer. Our 329,383 members are a testament to our reputation for professional business practices and unprecedented knowledge in the field of collectibles. Our mission is to provide the Internet's most indispensable trading platform and source of information for serious collectors, investors and dealers.

















