I very much appreciated your article referenced above on the proof Turtle Rock Bust Dime collection, and myself have a specimen dated 1829 that is beautiful and appears to be proof in many ways. I have not been able to establish the pedigree as I purchased it from a Heritage auction with limited information. But I purchased the coin coin because it looked spectacular from the photos, and I wanted to study it in detail.

I am a Lincoln Matte Proof enthusiast (see my resistry set at http://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/publishedset.aspx?s=43537 — I have gone to Ira Goldberg recently in search of my last MPL to fill my collection), and am out of my depth with these Bust Dimes, but find the coin and history fasinating, and the coin itself beautiful.

I could use the help of someone who has much more experience then myself. the coin is either a proof or gigh grade mint state NGC MS65. The variety is JR-3, R.4, the russet/blue toning and strike are even and beautiful, and it appears cameo when tilted to the light (The fields are watery, and contrast well with the devices). I’m sure that NGC will give it the highest JR-3 variety designation at it’s present MS65 rating, and star status, as the eye appeal is exceedingly attrative. I may have stumbled across a rarity, beyond the MS pop 1/0 status. But I am truly wondering if it is in fact proof, and would like to establish provenance, if possible. You seem to be the correct person to approach based on the article you wrote and your overall numismatic knowledge.

I can send JPEGS of the coin, or the coin itself, if that would be of help.

Is this something that would interest you, or do you have colleagues who specialize in Bust Dimes, who may be able to clarify the true status of this coin?

With appreciation.

Sincerely,

Duane Blake
duane.blake@comcast.net
781-492-2361