Unusual Items: 1913 Buffalo Nickel Struck on a Dime Planchet
Filed Under: Auction News, Errors, Heritage Auction Galleries, US Coins, Unusual Items
1913 5C Type Two Buffalo Nickel–Struck on a Dime Planchet–MS66 NGC. 2.5 gm, which is exactly the expected weight of an Uncirculated silver dime.
This remarkable wrong planchet error is predominantly silver-white, but the centers display a whisper of almond-gold toning. Luster shimmers across the immaculate surfaces, which display the finely granular texture characteristic of first-year Buffalo nickels.
Well struck despite the undersized flan, although slight incompleteness is noted on the hair above the braid, the jaw of the Indian, and the flank of the bison.
The date, designer’s initial, E PLURIBUS UNUM, and UNITED are intact. Portions of the other legends are off the flan, although all are readable. Remarkably, all of the Indian’s head is present, as is all of the bison except for the tail. Just enough of the exergue beneath the E C in FIVE CENTS to confirm that no mintmark is present.
Nickels struck on dime blanks are much scarcer than cents struck on dime blanks, but when the error combination is encountered, it is almost always on Jefferson dies.
The Buffalo nickel on silver dime planchet combination is priced at $12,000 in the 2010 Guide Book on page 403, the highest specified price on the page with the exception of the Walking Liberty half on a silver quarter planchet.
However, such prices are for examples in typically encountered grades, which for century-old issues usually imply brief circulation before a fortunate finder realized the uncommon color and diameter. A flawless MS66 certainly demands a considerable premium.
The invaluable Heritage Permanent Auction Archives, which date back to 1991, contain 8,277 lots of error coins. None of these are Buffalo nickels struck on dime planchets, although Buffalo nickels on cent planchets have occasionally appeared at auction. The present error category in such outstanding preservation may never surface again in a Heritage Signature, and the opportunity is fleeting.
To be sold By Heritage as Lot 2039 as part of the 2010 April-May Milwaukee, WI CSNS US Coin Auction #1139
- Unusual Items : Unique Quarter Eagle Struck on 3 Cent Nickel Planchet
- Newly Discovered 1831 Quarter Eagle Struck on a Dime Planchet
- Unusual Items: Remarkable Double Denomination Mule 1993-D Cent with Dime Reverse
- Unusual Items: 1906 Indian Cent. Struck in Gold
- Unusual Items : Enigmatic 1839-O Specimen Dime
- From the Grading Room: 1973-S Dollar on a Copper-Nickel Planchet
- Unusual Items: Unique “Six Cents” Coin
- Unusual Items: A Bizarre Territorial Gold Coin Overstrike
- Unusual Items: Martha Washingtom Die Trials
- Olsen-Hawn 1913 Liberty Nickel Sells for $3,737,500
About the Author
Heritage Auction Galleries is the world's largest collectibles auctioneer. Our 500,000+ members are a testament to our reputation for professional business practices and unprecedented knowledge in the field of collectibles. Our mission is to provide the Internet's most indispensable trading platform and source of information for serious collectors, investors and dealers.